Posted by
SciFiCCGuy on Wednesday, September 27, 2006 9:14:22 AM
These PBS House shows are fascinating! The lessons one can learn from the “experiment” are never less than intriguing, whether commenting on the human condition from centuries ago or from today. By taking people from modern times and having them “live in the past,” or as close an approximation to the past as possible, and filming it, commenting on it (the narrator this time is Randy Quaid) or having them comment on it, the experience is never less than stimulating, therefore entertaining.
Those who chose to participate this time included the Cooke family, the ones put in charge of an 1800’s Texas Ranch to turn a profit, and a group of guys who were to be the “cowboys,” mostly ranch hands and a few cooks, and a single girl to act as a house-girl or maid. The Cookes, and Mr. Cooke specifically, were given the task of making a profit on the ranch, which means organizing the cowboys, going on cattle drives, and delivering a herd to market in order to not just subsist as a working ranch, but thrive. For the point of this experiment, these people only had to survive this way for three months, but as the filmmakers point out many times during this eight episode run, real families, ranchers, and cowboys living back then didn’t have the luxury of driving back to a modern city to reenter life in the 21st century like these people did. If their ranch didn’t thrive, they could (and sometimes did) die. Watching all of this unfold was absorbing, as is usually the case with the PBS House shows.
The Cooke family consisted of husband Bill, wife Lisa, and daughters Vienna, Lacey, and Hannah, and the “girl of all work” who lived with them, Maura Finkelstein.
Other than the gruff foreman Stanley Johnston who was kicked off the ranch after a few days or weeks, the other cowboys were new ranch foreman Robby Cabezuela, cook Ignacio (Nacho) Quiles, Shaun Terhune, who took over Nacho’s job as cook when Nacho was fired, the English Johnny Ferguson, Anders Heintz, Ian Roberts, Jared Ficklin, and newcomer Rob Wright, who was “hired” by Mr. Cooke to replace some of the cowboys lost when Johnston and Nacho left.
The dynamics of the Cooke family and their relationship with the cowboys was the drama that kept the tension going, and of course, things were made even more interesting with the arrival of native American Indians, a merchant stopping by with supplies to buy, and the final trip to drop off the cattle at a local “fort” to sell about 200 head. How the audience interprets what happened with this ranch depends on how they might read these people, but here’s what I saw:
Mr. Cooke was whipped, and would make the difficult decisions only when prodded by his wife. Without her, he couldn’t stand on his own two feet; the cowboys knew it, and so did I. The only ones who didn’t seem to know it were the Cookes, and that includes those three pretty but almost invisible daughters. Mrs. Cooke was the one who wore the pants in the family and it drove her crazy that, for this time period and the purposes of this “experiment,” women had little or no power whatsoever. The running of the ranch was supposed to be the man’s responsibility. The problems in this experiment were caused because Mr. Cooke was indecisive and rather incompetent (the experts couldn’t make heads or tales of his expense ledger in the end), and the forced recommendations of his wife, who only saw things her way, didn’t sit well with the cowboys. It caused animosity to develop between the Cookes and the cowboys with Mr. Cooke caught in the middle, and when push came to shove, Mr. Cooke, of course, did what his wife said. Bill Cooke tried to justify it by stating their marriage was a partnership and their decisions for running things on the ranch were part of a two person committee, but in reality, Mr. Cooke, at least on camera and in these particular circumstances, didn’t seem to have a mind of his own, and it was Mrs. Cooke who okayed or dismissed all business pertaining to the ranch.
Take the whole Nacho/Shaun/Maura problem. When Nacho left the camp for being a lousy, disgustingly dirty cook and making all the cowboys sick, somebody had to fill in, and that somebody was Shaun, who graciously took over the job, leaving the other guys to go on all the cattle round-ups and drives. Part of the “fun” of this for the “cowboys” who volunteered for this “experiment” was to saddle up and ride, which Shaun could no longer do since he was tied down to duties as cook (which, by the way, he handled much better than Nacho, who is a professional chef in the real world). With former Ranch Forman Stanley Johnston and Nacho fired, the cowboys were down by two men since Robby and Shaun had to take over their responsibilities. To help fill the gap, Mr. Cooke hired newcomer Rob Wright and even participated in some of the cattle drives himself (of which the other cowboys were not too keen). Then Maura started talking about helping with the drive, showing an interest in “becoming” one of the cowboys since they were so short staffed. Prodded by Mrs. Cooke, Mr. Cooke caved in, and ordered Robby to find a spot for Maura on the team. Robby and the other cowboys complied reluctantly, and emotions were riding high for everybody: Maura, Robby, the cowboys, Mr. and Mrs. Cooke, and particularly Shaun, who took this like a slap in the face. Signing on to become a cowboy, he was then relegated to become the cook, and now, instead of letting him rejoin the other cowboys, Mr. Cooke (led by Mrs. Cooke, of course), was now instead going to let Maura ride with the other guys, which the other guys resented. I got the feeling Mr. Cooke actually felt sorry for Shaun and understood why he was understandably upset, but do you think Mrs. Cooke felt the same? Well of course she didn't! In Mrs. Cooke’s opinion, Shaun had better buckle down and keep that spatula in hand so that Maura can fill that needed spot on the cattle drive. And, of course, with no real voice of his own, Mr. Cooke was relegated to supporting his wife’s decision, just like always.
Or take for example that Indian affair that centered on poor old Jared, and which led to animosity at the end and the entire project falling apart! The cowboys were given a salary, just like any cowboy was given back then for the same job, and Jared saved his up and bought his own horse from Mr. Cooke. Well into the filming of this show, the producers worked onto the show the modern equivalent of an Indian tribe, who met with the cowboys while they were on the trail, and then “graciously” offered to have Jared and stay the night with them while the other cowboys returned to the ranch with word that the Indians would visit soon. When the Indians showed up, they were treated to hospitality 19th century Texas style. Believing the Indians to be amiable, Mr. Cooke played hardball with them when the Indians expressed interest in some of his cattle, and then discovered the Indians were actually, for all practical purposes, holding Jared and several or his own horses “hostage” and would return them for about 2 dozen head of cattle. Mr. Cooke agreed and got Jared and the horses back. When the show ended, however, Jared was told by Mr. Cooke that his horse, which he had bought from Mr. Cooke, was no longer his, because Mr. Cooke had to re-buy it back from the Indians. That didn’t sit well with Jared, nor the rest of the cowboys, and they all banded together in support of Jared and walked off the ranch with hurt feelings on both sides. In my humble opinion, however, the cowboys were more than justified! I would have walked off too!
Neither side wanted to get back together to discuss the success or failure of the ranch with the experts, but the experts came anyway, assessed the situation, and then sent letters to all participants, which the cowboys and the Cooke family read for the first time in front of the cameras from the security and comfort of their 21st century lives. And the experts’ assessment? A failure! Oh, not a complete failure to be sure, but a failure none the less, for although the ranch turned a profit this time, without any remaining ranch hands for the supposed following year, the Cooke ranch would have little chance of surviving, especially under Bill and Lisa Cooke’s control. Despite having a garden, the assessors were disturbed by the fact that the family rarely used it for food or side profit, and even more disturbing was the massive fly problem in the kitchen due to the garbage and chicken carcasses Mrs. Cooke left too close to the kitchen door.
The cowboys were thrilled with the assessment, and the Cookes were offended, as one might expect, and it all helps one to realize how a person may not be able to see the forest for the trees, especially when they are smack dab in the middle of it. But success or failure, these PBS House shows are one of the best reality shows on television. Other than having many of the aspects of other reality shows, they are also eye-opening and educational, as well as cultural and historical. You would probably have no reason to show something like Survivor or American Idol in a classroom, but kids can learn a lot from these PBS House shows (though they would still need to be trimmed and edited for a few more risqué moments – I remember for Colonial House, for instance, how the Voorhees family skipped church to go skinny dipping, an act that would have gotten them banned from the community or even lynched in real Colonial times). That’s the appeal of these shows: The entertainment and the education, and unlike Survivor, you actually feel smarter and wiser for having watched them.